A Velomobile for a Real Winter

After all the dire media hype about severe winter weather warnings here in the UK, we finally had a fall of wet slushy snow followed by a hard freeze.  The white traces that are left are not much to look at, and the ice, while a hazard for some, is not much compared to what was threatened, but there is now a wintery brightness in the crisp air which sets the mind going.  Now I know there are plenty of places further North or inland that have more snow than they could wish for, and where weather warnings really do warn about severe weather, but all the talk of snow and ice has set me wondering what options there are for winterised human powered transport.

The last video in the recent post about the Drymer trike and the video above, demonstrate that it is perfectly possible to take a human-powered, or even an eAssist trike out in the snow; and it is obvious that a velomobile body goes quite a way toward keeping the rider warm.  But what about something beyond this?  Going beyond the environmental rows over motorised snowmobile use in Yellowstone park, what about a human-powered snow-mobile?

Minds have already been exercised about this, and a mixture of concepts and products exist which tackle various aspects of the problem.

Concept drawing of Rolling Tundra SnowmobileThis concept for a track driven pedal-powered vehicle in skis by Michelle Marin, an industrial designer from Venice, Italy, did the rounds of the design blogs a couple of years ago.  As with most concepts there are technical niggles but the general idea is sound.  A lower seating position would be good and perhaps larger skis to handle soft snow and a better steering mechanism, something more like Akerman than a home made box car racer.

Ktrak Snowmobile Bike KitFollowing on from this concept, there already exists a commercial kit to convert a standard mountain bike to snowmobile mode.  The K-trak is a Canadian developed system where you swap out the front and rear wheels for a ski and tracked wheel assembly which fit directly into the respective fork drop-outs.  Thus allowing you to ride your bike through the snow much as you would in normal weather.  Regrettably the manufacturers site and online shop has gone offline but the following US promotional video gives a good idea

US adventurer Greg Kolodziejzyk has a review of the K-Track.  While his first impressions were positive he is much more cool about the K-Trak’s performance overall.  He sumarises the K-Trak system as being a very fun way to go down hill.

However Swis Catrike dealer Bike to the Future has fitted a Catrike with both skis and the K-Trak system and reports better success.  The secret it seems is achieving floatation in the snow, something that the MTB mounted K-Trak can only do at speed, i.e. downhill.

DSC04694Greg’s original purpose for the K-Trak was to enable him to maintain an all-year cycle training program to support his other pedal powered projects, but perhaps another motivation was to test the design for suitability for his plan to pedal across the Greenland Icecap.  As he notes on the initial concept page, there are no developed plans as yet, but one of the concepts is a track driven velomobile on skis.

Concept drawing of Ice Liner Inside ViewConcept drawing of Ice LinerLarge skis and a larger track system should help with the floatation but one does wonder how the head-in configuration would perform when it comes to window fog.  Unless a successful anti-fog coating or system be applied to the canopy, it is likely that a head-out configuration would be more successful.

While drag reduction due to vehicle speed would be a none issue; reduction of drag due to opposing wind, such as one would expect to meet with on the ice-cap, would still be a very good idea.  Also a fairing or enclosure, covering the feet and legs at least, would also be very valuable; as David Gordon Wilson suggests in an editorial in Issue 28, and further hints regarding an observation by Philip Thiel in Issue 29 of Human Power; this would prevent heat loss due to pedalling motion.

Greenspeed, Australian recumbent trike builder, has experimented with the Snow-Trike concept and successfully built the following tracked trike using off-the-shelf components for a motorised vehicle.  Please excuse the background noise music, not my choice.

Another home builder has fitted both skis track to his recumbent only in the opposite configuration with the track up-front.

A Finnish HPV enthusiast, inspired by an 1885 Ice-Velocipede, has been experimenting with a Cycle-Ski, but apart from a single page outlining the project and the following short video there is nothing more.

Searches for for more information turned up: a patent for a HP Snowmobile; a project to develop a human-pedal-powered caterpillar-drive; and some information about ski-bikes.

Ski-bikes are purely downhill machines, and currently exist to serve a niche sport.  A history of Ski-Bikes is given on the following pages. and kits such as this one from Alpine Ski Bikes can be used to convert a typical MTB but there is absolutely no drive mechanism, just gravity.

I was unable to find much else.  I would be interested to know what work, if any, has been done by others; and also to hear any further thoughts or comments.  So please add your thoughts via the comment form below.

 

 

Twike – Human-electric-hybrid featured on Treehugger

The Twike is one of those vehicles that really pushes the definition of velomobile to it’s limits.  A two seater sociable delta trike it relies heavily (pun not intended) on a large lithium  battery pack to augment the mechanical power provided by the two riders.  First displayed at the World Expo in Vancouver in 1986.  In production since 1992 the 1000th machine recently left the factory in Germany.

Photo of row of TwikesChristine Lepisto visited the manufacturer and has written an article on Treehugger, covering the history and giving an overview of the technology used in the Twike.  In this article she attempts to ask the questions:

  • What value does pedal-power add to a vehicle that must compete with traffic and over typical commuting distances?
  • Is an HPV/EV hybrid the world’s best citycar?
  • What are the challenges when you take a TWIKE on tour?
  • What is the lowest cost per mile that can be hyper-miled out of a TWIKE?
  • Can people improve their fitness with an HPV/EV Hybrid?
  • Is there still a place for a 20-year old human-powered EV design in a world where Teslas command the “EV sportscar” headlines and most major car manufacturers have an EV on or coming to the market? And closely related, is the EV trend killing human-powered vehicles (HPVs)?

Christine writes from a “Green Motorist’s” perspective, comparing the Twike favourably to the Tesla electic car.  However she concludes pessimistically that the Twike will remain a niche product while the rest of the world will turn to vehicles that reflect what they have always used.

While the perspective and the product are not fully aligned with the machines we usually look at, the article is none-the-less well worth reading.  The writing is somewhat terse and there are areas where one would like to know more detail but as an overview it is helpful.

Photo of Twike TW4XP

Christine concludes with a reference to the TW4XP (TWIKE 4 the X-Prize) which took 3rd place in the Progressive Automotive X Prize and asks if this is a preview of the next generation.

 

Sinner and Drymer are now partners

Sinner MangoFrom a post on Ligfiets.net we learn that Sinner Bikes, makers of the Mango velomobile, and Drymer, manufacturer of the eAssist Drymer tilting trike, which comes with an optional fairing, have entered into a partnership.  One of the first outcomes of this partnership is that the manufacture of the Mango is to be moved from Groningen to Stadskanaal, where the Drymer is currently produced.

DrymerWe mentioned the relaunch and commencement of commercial manufacture of the Drymer last summer, after WITEC bought out Drymer which had been suffering from financial difficulties.  That Sinner has entered into this partnership should not come as much of a surprise as they were involved in the original consortium that first developed the Drymer concept.  It would also seem to be consistent with the recent news that Sinner are dropping their line of recumbent bikes focusing instead on the Comfort delta trike and the Mango velomobile.  It would seem very reasonable to expect that this co-location would bring benefits to both businesses which will translate into the current products of both, but more than that, one can begin to imagine what new and improved machines might be developed and brought to market.

In the same ligfiets article we also learn that Sinner are continuing to develop the Mango and are now offering an alternative upper body.  Called an Aero-top it features a “viewing-slot” down the centre, comparable to the upper body shape of the WAW, Evo-K and Alligt A8.  This is touted as giving not only improved road vision for the rider but also providing some improve aerodynamics.  Ligfiets however observe that the new shape will likely impact on the usability of the interior space.  An example of the new upper is seen here mounted on the wall.

magotopmetsleuf

Returning to the Drymer we are refered to a blog by Philip Smits, Dagboek van een Drymerrijder.  Philip now has a Drymer Leisure, the trike without the fairing, and has been blogging his experiences over the last few weeks.  He has also produced a few videos.  Below is one which gives a good overview with commentary in Dutch.

The following give a short, and cheerful, rider’s view in the snow.

Minor personal niggles aside Philips report of the performance is very positive.

ELF velomobile surpasses Kickstarter goal

Photo of ELF velomobile and staff outside Organic Transit's premisesOrganic Transit’s Kickstarter project has been a huge success.  “Roll out the ELF to your City,” finished this weekend $225,789 was raised from 547 backers against a goal of $100,000.  That is a stagering 225% and almost double the amount pledged when we mentioned the project 3 weeks ago.

There is the following brief comment on Organic Transit’s facebook page:

Kickstarter is over and we more than doubled our goal!
Tiny vehicles that don’t pollute can now move forward and have positive effects globally.

This is the start of something really SMALL!

Thank you all.

We look forward to more “smallness” to come.

Road HAWK – A new Velomobile Design being developed in Poland

Photo mock-up of the Road HAWK velomobile A new Velomobile design, the Road HAWK, is currently being developed by WEJKAMA, a company in Poland.  The company is well established, currently serving the automotive world with a number of fiberglass products products, principally a sleeping compartment that can be installed on a number of delivery vehicles for long distance freight haulage.

Photo of Road HAWK bodyAs an existing company with all the skills needed to produce velomobile bodies the potential looks good.  However the information on their website, while interesting, is rather scanty when it come to technical detail.  The image featured above is evidently a photo-mock-up, but it does appear to be based on a body prototype to which some wheels have been attached.  The hard part will be in getting the details right including successfully developing the mechanical side.

A short report on Ligfiets.net adds details about price (€4,500+) and weight.  They also make an interesting comparison with the Flevobike Orca and the Sunrider, currently under development with Alligt.  This is interesting since Alligt source their fibreglass bodies from a Polish supplier and WEJKAMA are also advertising  body-building services to other velomobile producers.  Whether WEJKAMA supply Alligt is not known but it does seem likely that they already have experience with some existing velomobile body construction.

At present there is one other known Polish velomobile producer, Car-Bike who used to supply the original Cab-Bike with their bodies, and then took over the production when Cab-bike ceased trading at the start of 2012.  Car-bike’s website is similarly short on information and, after restyling the original Cab-bike and demonstrating a two-seater (sociable) velomobile at SPEZI in 2011, not much has been heard from them.  However there is word that this may be about to change.  There is also talk that they may revert to the original Cab-bike name as the Car-bike name is already owned in Germany by the developers of a human-electric hybrid multi-seater vehicle.

Concept drawings of Road HAWK velomobileThe above drawings, from Wejkama’s site, also indicate plans to offer the Road HAWK in multiple configurations with both a head-in, “Cabin,” as well as a head-out, “Cabrio,” model.  Similar to Wejkama, Car-bike/Cab-bike also offer(ed) a Cabin and a Cabrio model and one cannot help making a connection.  We await with interest to see how the Road HAWK continues to develop this year.

Carbon Rotovelo

rotovelo-carbon-sideTrisled have brought out a new variant of the Rotovelo, their robust budget priced velomobile.  The Rotovelo Carbon is, as it’s name suggests, is made in the same shape as the original Rotovelo but with a body of carbon fibre instead of the original roto-molded HDPE.  We briefly mentioned the body material advantage of the original design in a post regarding the sale of the machine reviewed by Velovision Magazine (Issue 41 Jun 2011).

What was not mentioned was the bare-bones spec, which includes no installed suspension system and simple cruciform frame, since the body is not sufficiently capable of carrying load.  The specification is justified as part of a design whose objective is robust simplicity and low cost.  That this bare-bones spec has been translated directly to a machine with a costly and relatively fragile body has raised a lot of comment and questions along the lines of, “what are they thinking!?”

The following short video by Trisled illustrates the Rotovelo Carbon in action.

A typical velomobile can be expected to weight upward of 30 kg with the sporty machines weighing in the mid 20s.  Perhaps the lightest of these is the Go-one Evo-Ks at 21.5 kg for the bare model.  What Trisled have achieved with the Rotovelo Carbon is a low weight – obviously depending on component choice, as low as 19.5 kg (the same weight as my Claude Butler run-about bike!)  Given the attractive weight there are some saying, if the Rotovelo Carbon came with suspension they would have one, and it is claimed to be the most asked for feature for the original Rotovelo, so what gives?

Firstly there is a weight saving by excluding active suspension, so the record low would not be possible otherwise.  Secondly there is a helpful and fairly extensive rider report on the Rotovelo on the Bentrider Online forum by mikeatlbch which gives a more balanced perspective and argues that for most practical cases active suspension is not needed.  One thing he highlights from his own experience is the passive suspension provided by the Rotovelo frame.  While he still prefers the HDPE body for its ability to take the knocks he appreciates the value low weight would offer in a stop-and-go urban environment where ease of acceleration and therefore low weight is important.

So while the armchair velonaut, accustomed to ever increasing technical complexity, may be puzzled: what Trisled have produced is, from their perspective, a logical compromise; satisfied with the ride performance of the original Rotovelo, they have traded a robust body for easier acceleration.  It remains to be seen whether there are buyers who agree with them.

Oliebollentocht – Record Number of Velomobiles

Oliebollentocht Logo157 velomobiles participated in the 2012 Oliebollentocht, upping the record from 149 in 2011.  The day was clear and relatively warm for the time of year, which made for some good photography, and photos and videos from riders and others, are now appearing online.  Several are linked to from the Ligfiets page.

The ride commenced in Zwolle and, after counting for the record, the velomobiles left in groups of about 50.  Looking at the videos it is fair to say that the Quest and Strada velomobiles represented the largest group.  However there is a surprisingly large selection of machines to be seen, these included: Flevobike Orca/Versatile; various iterations of Alligt and Flevo Alleweders; WAW; Milan; a couple of Go-One Evo Ks; Velayo; and even a Leiba Classic.  The following video takes you on a wander round the parked velomobiles assembling for the ride.  The Duo Quest with a trailer also participated and is featured early in the video.  It is clear from what is shown, that at least three children could be transported in this way, though I read a report on the Strada 112 A blog that there were four children carried!

The following video also takes you around the assembling velomobiles but also includes some of the ride itself with a mixture of cockpit views and stills which all help to give a flavour of the day.

The next video is quite long at 24 minutes, but features an extensive cockpit eye view taken from a Quest equipped with a carbon race-cap.  The view is not all from the cockpit as the rider gets out several times including after rolling onto the ferry at Genemuiden.  It is amusing to see the small ferry overwhelmed by the number of velomobiles all trying to cross at the same time.  I believe Andre Vrielink can be seen on the ferry with a similar, if not the same, Orca that I test-rode last September.

The following is a much shorter video but with rather flashy production including quite a number of shots in fast-play, which create their own effect and impression.

To conclude there follows a compilation of well-shot video of one group en-route and obviously enjoying themselves.  David Hembrow of A View From the Cycle Path is featured smiling at the camera as he passes in his Mango.

Organic Transit’s ‘ELF’ Velomobile on Kickstarter

Photo of white ELF velomobileThe ELF is a relatively large electric assist velomobile currently being developed by Organic Transit in the US.  Australian Tech Blog Gizmag recently posted an article highlighting the combined human and solar power sources utilised by the ELF, and also the proposed price of $4,000, which they compared favourably to two other North American produced velombiles, the Hornet ($5,700) and the Tripod ($7,450).

Organic Transit (OT) have adopted a somewhat different design approach to their velomobile, and that, combined with a Kickstarter campaign, is the secret to the relatively low cost.  The campaign has been very successful so far, and, with more than 3 weeks still remaining, they have raised more than 125% of the original $100,000 goal.  They have already produced several prototypes which have been used to refine the design and build process.  Their plan is to release the first 100 production units through Kickstarter.

As is customary on Kickstarter a promotional video has been produced highlighting the proposed product. This can be viewed below.  There is also a fairly extensive write up of the development process that OT has gone through to reach this stage on their Kickstarter page.  It is particularly interesting that they plan to replace a hand-laid GRP process, that takes two hours to build a body panel, with a vacuum moulded ABS process that takes a mere 12 minutes!

From the above sources and the OT FAQ several interesting facts can be gleaned.

Orgainc Transit are primarily based in Durham, North Carolina but have team members in several states.  The team behind the ELF are professional with strong connections to the US Human Powered Vehicle movement.  Perhaps the most well known is C. Michael Lewis, who will be known to some as the artist behind numerous velomobile and HPV posters, such as those for Battle Mountain and ROAM.

Photo of ELF velomobile and staff outside Organic Transit's premises While currently operating out of a former furniture store in downtown Durham, they have ambitions not only to sell the ELF, and it’s stable-mate the TruckIt, but more globally, to set up micro-factories producing the ELF in “every downtown.”  To-date they have had enquiries from many places, including Europe, and they are seriously looking into ways to supply markets further afield than the US.

OT have followed the “Keep it simple” philosophy and are quite clear that they are not intending to compete with the more established, and more aerodynamic, velomobiles such as the Quest and the Mango.  Their target is the thoroughly practical user who wants a highly visible vehicle with a large carrying capability and to whom speed is not a significant consideration.  Hence the ELF is large – 8′ x 43″ x 5′ (2.4 x 1 x 1.5 m) and heavy – 100 lbs (45 kg).

To avoid the cost and complexity of suspension, OT have opted to use the standard MTB size of 26″ on all wheels, with large diameter tyres to smooth the ride.  While simpler this does pose a concern as the front wheels will have to resist lateral forces not normally experienced by bicycle wheels and these forces are a function of the vehicle weight.  The consensus so far on successful trikes and velomobiles has been to restrict the size of these wheels to not more than 20″.

Photo of an ELF prototype parked in the streatThe purist will reject the reliance on electric assist and there has been some perhaps unfair criticism of the ELF’s weight, but this should not be an undue problem for the intended user.  However, as there is reference to options to add: doors, floor and other extras; one can see the weight rising as the design begins to bloat.  One nice feature is the integrated solar panels which allow the batteries to be trickle charged during the day, assuming access to adequate sunlight.  Otherwise the standard battery pack takes two hours to charge.

To conform to regulations, allowing the ELF to be classified as a bike, assisted top-speed is limited to 20 mph (32 km/h), but there is no reason why the rider can’t push the vehicle faster if they have the strength or gravity on their side.  The following video is taken from an ELF driver’s eye view, about mid way through you hear a conversation between the ELF’s rider and a truck-driver about the potential speeds.

While the debate about “fast cycles” continues to rumble on, the current regulations, particularly those in Europe, that govern e-bikes and their classification impose relatively onerous requirements on vehicles that are classed as “more than a bike”.  This makes it challenging to successfully develop and market a vehicle of this type.  A recent article on the Low Tech Magazine blog, albeit featuring the highly aerodynamic WAW velomobile, argues the virtues of electric assisted velomobiles, much of which  applies to the ELF, the second part of the article also goes into some of the issues with the current legislation.

One velomobile mentioned by the Low Tech article is the 55 kg Aerorider, developed in the mid 2000s.  This vehicle with many similar attributes to the ELF failed to be commercially successful due to a combination of high cost, weight and the limitations imposed by regulation.  It would be reasonable to say that if regulation had been favourable for a class of “fast bikes” the Aerorider would have done much better.  As it stands the Aerorider was redesigned as the Sunrider which has now passed into the hands of Alligt, and Alligt are doing their part to lobby for a fast-bike class (snelfiets).  As Alligt now have access to the moulds and tooling for the original Aerorider, should regulations change, one never knows, the Aerorider may ride again.  Hopefully the ELF will continue to progress and, though lower cost, a different market and simplicity, be more successful than the Aerorider proved to be.

Velomobile News from Holland

A couple of news items from Holland.

Sinner to Cease Recumbent Bike Production?

According to Ligtfiets.net Sinner is to stop producing the Demon and Spirit recumbent bikes, instead concentrating their efforts on the Comfort delta trike and the Mango velomobile.  A quick review of the Sinner website turned up no information but Ligtfiets advise that existing stock of the Spirit and Demon will continue to be sold.

Mark 2 Sunrider is to be made available as a kit and branded the Alligt A9

Alligt have a photo of the new Sunrider body with the different elements highlighted in one of the three standard body colours.  There is a caveat that the actual shade of yellow will be slightly different from that shown, but it gives a nice idea of how the finished machine is assembled.  The most obvious changes are the the rear of the body with a squarer ending reminiscent of the Versatile/Orca but there are quite a number of other more subtle changes to the body which should improve water-tightness and sound.

Alligt A9 body in colourWhat is not visible here are the substantial sub-frame and numerous standard Alligt components that have been incorporated into the design.

The particularly interesting news is that the Sunrider will be available as a self build kit along side the A4, A6, A7 and A8.  Not too surprisingly the kit will be sold as the A9.

Prices in Euros are available via the Alligt website but to summarise, depending on options: the A9 kit will range from 4,195 to 7,395; and a completed Sunrider ranges from 6,595 to 8,895.  A “Moped” class Sunrider is also available suitable for type-approval in Germany for 10,595.Photo of mark 2 Sunrider prototype

 

Roll Over America – The Book!

ROAM logoThe Roll Over America (ROAM) velomobile tour which took place in 2011 is now documented in book form.  Available either as an iBook for iOS 5 or 210 Mb PDF from Google Docs, Josef Janning chronicles the story of the first ever velomobile tour across the United States from Oregon to Washington D.C.  The 210 pages cover the 28 day, 5300 km journey in detail, together with additional material and comments from riders and observers.

Cover of ROAM the storyAs one would expect the opening chapter deals with the background and planning for the tour.  The book also closes with a number of after thoughts and hints at possible future tours of a similar kind in both the US and other parts of the world.

It is good to see ROAM documented in this, more permanent, fashion as the original site at http://www.rolloveramerica.eu, while reserved, no longer has any content accessible, demonstrating the frustratingly short life cycle of too much of the information available on the internet.